A simple decision guide
- Want it done today with no fees? Sell to a specialist buyer.
- Have time and want to chase top gross price? List individually online and absorb the fees and risk.
- Just need quick cash and don't mind a low offer? A pawn shop works.
- Own a rare, high-grade key card? Get a specialist offer first, then weigh auction.
What to prepare before selling
- Sleeve and protect anything valuable.
- Sort by set, rarity, and graded vs. raw.
- Note any PSA/BGS/CGC certification numbers.
- Take sharp photos of fronts and backs.
Sell with Card Buyers
Upload your photos, get a free no-obligation offer based on the live market, and pick same-day in-person cash or free insured mail-in.
Instant photo quote
See what your card is worth — scan it
Snap a photo for a free, no-obligation offer in seconds. Same-day cash for local meetups in Hicksville & NYC.
- Offer in seconds
- Free insured shipping
Snap a card, slab label, or sealed box for an instant price.
Secure
Same Day Pay
No Fees
No Obligation
Related Questions
Where do I sell if I only have a few cards?
Even small lots are welcome. Upload photos and we will make an offer or tell you honestly if they are bulk.
Do I have to ship, or can I come in?
Both options exist — visit our Hicksville, NY storefront for instant cash, or mail in free with same-day payment.
How do you decide what my cards are worth?
We price against current sold listings and graded comps, then factor in condition and demand.