Expert Answer

Where can I sell Pokemon cards near NYC for cash today?

Quick Answer

Card Buyers has a Pokemon card buying store in Hicksville, Long Island, on the LIRR Main Line from Penn Station. Walk in Monday-Friday, 11 AM-5 PM, for a free in-person offer and same-day payment on graded slabs, vintage holos, sealed product and full collections. If you cannot visit, scan your cards at cardbuyers.com/sell and ship them free and insured.

Call (516) 934-0057

Selling in person near New York City

  • Store: Card Buyers, 244 W Old Country Rd Unit 1, Hicksville, NY 11801
  • Hours: Monday-Friday 11 AM-5 PM, closed weekends
  • Getting there: Hicksville is a stop on the LIRR Main Line from Penn Station and Grand Central Madison. By car it is off the Long Island Expressway and Northern State Parkway.
  • Payment: same day, once we have looked at the cards.

What to bring

Graded slabs (PSA, BGS, CGC), vintage holos, sealed booster boxes and ETBs, binders and bulk. Bring a photo ID.

Not able to come in?

Scan your cards at cardbuyers.com/sell for an instant offer and ship them with a free insured label.

Instant photo quote

See what your card is worth — scan it

Snap a photo for a free, no-obligation offer in seconds. Same-day cash for local meetups in Hicksville & NYC.

  • Offer in seconds
  • Free insured shipping
Upload sheet Beta

Snap a card, slab label, or sealed box for an instant price.

Secure
Same Day Pay
No Fees
No Obligation

Related Questions

Do I need an appointment?

No. Walk in during store hours. For very large collections, calling ahead helps us set aside time.

Do you have a store in Manhattan, Brooklyn or Queens?

Not yet. Our store is in Hicksville on Long Island, reachable by LIRR. Anywhere else, you can sell by mail.

Get a Free Offer on Your Pokemon Cards Today

Snap a photo and get a real cash offer — no obligation, no fees.

244 W Old Country Rd Unit 1, Hicksville, NY