How to avoid scams when selling online
- Use insured, tracked shipping so your cards are protected in transit.
- Get a clear written offer before you ship anything.
- Verify the buyer — reviews, real business address, contact info.
- Avoid off-platform payment requests and "pay you later" promises.
- Keep records — photos, tracking, and offer confirmation.
The safe way with Card Buyers
- Upload photos for a free, written, no-obligation offer.
- Accept, and we email a free insured prepaid label.
- Ship with tracking; your cards are insured in transit.
- Get same-day payment once received and verified.
You can also skip shipping entirely and sell in person at our Hicksville, NY storefront for instant cash.
Instant photo quote
See what your card is worth — scan it
Snap a photo for a free, no-obligation offer in seconds. Same-day cash for local meetups in Hicksville & NYC.
- Offer in seconds
- Free insured shipping
Snap a card, slab label, or sealed box for an instant price.
Secure
Same Day Pay
No Fees
No Obligation
Related Questions
Is it safe to mail valuable Pokemon cards?
Yes, when shipping is insured and tracked. We provide free insured labels and pay the same day cards arrive and are verified.
How do I know a buyer is legitimate?
Look for a real business address, reviews, transparent pricing, and a written offer — all of which we provide.
What payment methods are safe?
We pay by cash in person or trusted electronic methods like PayPal, Venmo, and Zelle after verification.